John McMurry, Professor Emeritus

19.11 Nucleophilic Addition of Phosphorus Ylides: The Wittig Reaction

19.11 • Nucleophilic Addition of Phosphorus Ylides: The Wittig Reaction

Aldehydes and ketones are converted into alkenes by means of a nucleophilic addition called the Wittig reaction, after the German chemist Georg Wittig who won the 1979 Nobel Prize in Chemistry. The reaction has no direct biological counterpart but is important both because of its wide use in drug manufacture and because of its mechanistic similarity to reactions of the coenzyme thiamin diphosphate, which we’ll see in Section 29.6.

In the Wittig reaction, a triphenylphosphorus ylide, $R_{2} \bar{C} - \overset{+}{P} {Ph}_{3}$ also called a phosphorane and sometimes written in the resonance form $R_{2} C═ {P(Ph)}_{3}$ , adds to an aldehyde or ketone to yield a four-membered cyclic intermediate called an oxaphosphetane. The oxaphosphetane is not isolated, but instead spontaneously decomposes to give an alkene plus triphenylphosphine oxide, $O═ {PPh}_{3}$ . In effect, the oxygen atom of the aldehyde or ketone and the R₂C= bonded to phosphorus exchange places. (An ylide—pronounced ill-id—is a neutral, dipolar compound with adjacent positive and negative charges.)

An aldehyde or ketone reacts with ylide to form an oxaphosphetane. This further forms alkene plus triphenylphosphine oxide.

The initial addition takes place by different pathways depending on the structure of the reactants and the exact experimental conditions. One pathway involves a one-step cycloaddition process analogous to the Diels–Alder cycloaddition reaction (Section 14.4). The other pathway involves a nucleophilic addition reaction to give a dipolar intermediate called a betaine (bay-ta-een), which undergoes ring closure.

A cyclic reversible reaction where aldehyde or ketone reacts with ylide, to form betaine (intermediate), which further forms oxaphosphetane. This transforms back to the reactants, aldehyde or ketone and ylide.

The phosphorus ylides necessary for Wittig reaction are easily prepared by S_N2 reaction of primary (and some secondary) alkyl halides with triphenylphosphine, (Ph)₃P, followed by treatment with base. Triphenylphosphine is a good nucleophile in S_N2 reactions, and yields of the resultant alkyltriphenylphosphonium salts are high. Because of the positive charge on phosphorus, the hydrogen on the neighboring carbon is weakly acidic and can be removed by a strong base such as butyllithium (BuLi) to generate the neutral ylide. For example:

Triphenylphosphine reacts with bromomethane via an S N 2 reaction to produce methyltriphenylphosphonium bromide, which then reacts with B u L i and T H F to form methylenetriphenylphosphorane.

The Wittig reaction is extremely general, and a great many monosubstituted, disubstituted, and trisubstituted alkenes can be prepared from the appropriate combination of phosphorane and aldehyde or ketone. Tetrasubstituted alkenes, however, can’t be prepared this way because of steric hindrance.

The real value of the Wittig reaction is that it yields a pure alkene of predictable structure. The $C═C$ bond in the product is always exactly where the $C═O$ group was in the reactant, and no alkene isomers (except E,Z isomers) are formed. For example, Wittig reaction of cyclohexanone with methylenetriphenylphosphorane yields only the single alkene product methylenecyclohexane. By contrast, addition of methylmagnesium bromide to cyclohexanone, followed by dehydration with POCl₃, yields a roughly 9 : 1 mixture of two alkenes.

Cyclohexanone reacts with methylmagnesium bromide, then phosphoryl trichloride, forming1-methylcyclohexene and methylenecyclohexane in 9: 1 ratio. It also reacts with methylenenetriphenylphosphorane and tetrahydrofuran to form methylenecyclohexane and Ph 3 P O.

Wittig reactions are used commercially in the synthesis of numerous pharmaceutical products. For example, the German chemical company BASF prepares vitamin A by using a Wittig reaction between a 15-carbon ylide and a 5-carbon aldehyde.

A reaction where fifteen-carbon ylide, carbon-carbon aldehyde react in the presence of methanol, and sodium methoxide form vitamin A acetate.

Worked Example 19.3

Synthesizing an Alkene Using a Wittig Reaction

What carbonyl compound and what phosphorus ylide might you use to prepare 3-ethyl-2-pentene?

Strategy

An aldehyde or ketone reacts with a phosphorus ylide to yield an alkene in which the oxygen atom of the carbonyl reactant is replaced by the ═CR₂ of the ylide. Preparation of the phosphorus ylide itself usually involves S_N2 reaction of a primary alkyl halide with triphenylphosphine, so the ylide is typically primary,

RCH═ {P(Ph)}_{3}

. This means that the disubstituted alkene carbon in the product comes from the carbonyl reactant, while the monosubstituted alkene carbon comes from the ylide.

Solution

3-pentanone reacts with a compound containing (P h) 3 P cation bonded to C H negative C H 3 and T H F, to form 3-ethyl-2-pentene.

Problem 19-16

What carbonyl compound and what phosphorus ylide might you use to prepare each of the following compounds?

(a)

(b)

(c)

(d)

(e)

(f)

Problem 19-17

β-Carotene, a yellow food-coloring agent and dietary source of vitamin A can be prepared by a double Wittig reaction between 2 equivalents of β-ionylideneacetaldehyde and a diylide. Show the structure of the β-carotene product.