4.4 Lewis Symbols and Structures

Lewis Symbols

We use Lewis symbols to describe valence electron configurations of atoms and monatomic ions. A Lewis symbol consists of an elemental symbol surrounded by one dot for each of its valence electrons:

Figure 4.10 shows the Lewis symbols for the elements of the third period of the periodic table.

Figure 4.10 Lewis symbols illustrating the number of valence electrons for each element in the third period of the periodic table.

Lewis symbols can also be used to illustrate the formation of cations from atoms, as shown here for sodium and calcium:

Likewise, they can be used to show the formation of anions from atoms, as shown here for chlorine and sulfur:

Figure 4.11 demonstrates the use of Lewis symbols to show the transfer of electrons during the formation of ionic compounds.

Figure 4.11 Cations are formed when atoms lose electrons, represented by fewer Lewis dots, whereas anions are formed by atoms gaining electrons. The total number of electrons does not change.

Lewis Structures

We also use Lewis symbols to indicate the formation of covalent bonds, which are shown in Lewis structures, drawings that describe the bonding in molecules and polyatomic ions. For example, when two chlorine atoms form a chlorine molecule, they share one pair of electrons:

The Lewis structure indicates that each Cl atom has three pairs of electrons that are not used in bonding (called lone pairs) and one shared pair of electrons (written between the atoms). A dash (or line) is sometimes used to indicate a shared pair of electrons:

A single shared pair of electrons is called a single bond. Each Cl atom interacts with eight valence electrons: the six in the lone pairs and the two in the single bond.

The Octet Rule

The other halogen molecules (F₂, Br₂, I₂, and At₂) form bonds like those in the chlorine molecule: one single bond between atoms and three lone pairs of electrons per atom. This allows each halogen atom to have a noble gas electron configuration. The tendency of main group atoms to form enough bonds to obtain eight valence electrons is known as the octet rule.

The number of bonds that an atom can form can often be predicted from the number of electrons needed to reach an octet (eight valence electrons); this is especially true of the nonmetals of the second period of the periodic table (C, N, O, and F). For example, each atom of a group 14 element has four electrons in its outermost shell and therefore requires four more electrons to reach an octet. These four electrons can be gained by forming four covalent bonds, as illustrated here for carbon in CCl₄ (carbon tetrachloride) and silicon in SiH₄ (silane). Because hydrogen only needs two electrons to fill its valence shell, it is an exception to the octet rule. The transition elements and inner transition elements also do not follow the octet rule:

Group 15 elements such as nitrogen have five valence electrons in the atomic Lewis symbol: one lone pair and three unpaired electrons. To obtain an octet, these atoms form three covalent bonds, as in NH₃ (ammonia). Oxygen and other atoms in group 16 obtain an octet by forming two covalent bonds:

Double and Triple Bonds

As previously mentioned, when a pair of atoms shares one pair of electrons, we call this a single bond. However, a pair of atoms may need to share more than one pair of electrons in order to achieve the requisite octet. A double bond forms when two pairs of electrons are shared between a pair of atoms, as between the carbon and oxygen atoms in CH₂O (formaldehyde) and between the two carbon atoms in C₂H₄ (ethylene):

A triple bond forms when three electron pairs are shared by a pair of atoms, as in carbon monoxide (CO) and the cyanide ion (CN^–):

Writing Lewis Structures with the Octet Rule

For very simple molecules and molecular ions, we can write the Lewis structures by merely pairing up the unpaired electrons on the constituent atoms. See these examples:

For more complicated molecules and molecular ions, it is helpful to follow the step-by-step procedure outlined here:

1. Determine the total number of valence (outer shell) electrons. For cations, subtract one electron for each positive charge. For anions, add one electron for each negative charge.
2. Draw a skeleton structure of the molecule or ion, arranging the atoms around a central atom. (Generally, the least electronegative element should be placed in the center.) Connect each atom to the central atom with a single bond (one electron pair).
3. Distribute the remaining electrons as lone pairs on the terminal atoms (except hydrogen), completing an octet around each atom.
4. Place all remaining electrons on the central atom.
5. Rearrange the electrons of the outer atoms to make multiple bonds with the central atom in order to obtain octets wherever possible.

Let us determine the Lewis structures of SiH₄, ${\text{CHO}}_2{}^{\text{−}},$ NO⁺, and OF₂ as examples in following this procedure:

1. Determine the total number of valence (outer shell) electrons in the molecule or ion.
   • For a molecule, we add the number of valence electrons on each atom in the molecule:
     
     $$\begin{array}{l}\\ {\text{SiH}}_4\\ \text{Si: 4 valence electrons/atom}\times \text{1 atom}=4\\ \underset{¯}{+\text{H: 1 valence electron/atom}\times \text{4 atoms}=4}\\ \\ =\text{8 valence electrons}\end{array}$$
   • For a negative ion, such as ${\text{CHO}}_2{}^{\text{−}},$ we add the number of valence electrons on the atoms to the number of negative charges on the ion (one electron is gained for each single negative charge):
     
     $$\begin{array}{l}\\ {\text{CHO}}_2{}^{\text{−}}\\ \text{C: 4 valence electrons/atom}\times \text{1 atom}=4\\ \text{H: 1 valence electron/atom}\times \text{1 atom}=1\\ \text{O: 6 valence electrons/atom}\times \text{2 atoms}=12\\ \underset{¯}{+\text{1 additional electron}=1}\\ \\ =\text{18 valence electrons}\end{array}$$
   • For a positive ion, such as NO⁺, we add the number of valence electrons on the atoms in the ion and then subtract the number of positive charges on the ion (one electron is lost for each single positive charge) from the total number of valence electrons:
     
     $$\begin{array}{}\\ \\ {\text{NO}}^{+}\\ \text{N: 5 valence electrons/atom}\times \text{1 atom}=5\\ \\ \text{O: 6 valence electron/atom}\times \text{1 atom}=6\\ \underset{¯}{+\text{−1 electron (positive charge)}=\mathrm{-1}}\\ \\ =\text{10 valence electrons}\end{array}$$
   • Since OF₂ is a neutral molecule, we simply add the number of valence electrons:
     
     $$\begin{array}{l}\\ {\text{OF}}_{\text{2}}\\ \text{O: 6 valence electrons/atom}\times \text{1 atom}=6\\ \underset{¯}{+\text{F: 7 valence electrons/atom}\times \text{2 atoms}=14}\\ =\text{20 valence electrons}\end{array}$$
2. Draw a skeleton structure of the molecule or ion, arranging the atoms around a central atom and connecting each atom to the central atom with a single (one electron pair) bond. (Note that we denote ions with brackets around the structure, indicating the charge outside the brackets:)
   
   When several arrangements of atoms are possible, as for ${\text{CHO}}_2{}^{\text{−}},$ we must use experimental evidence to choose the correct one. In general, the less electronegative elements are more likely to be central atoms. In ${\text{CHO}}_2{}^{\text{−}},$ the less electronegative carbon atom occupies the central position with the oxygen and hydrogen atoms surrounding it. Other examples include P in POCl₃, S in SO₂, and Cl in ${\text{ClO}}_4{}^{\text{−}}.$ An exception is that hydrogen is almost never a central atom. As the most electronegative element, fluorine also cannot be a central atom.
3. Distribute the remaining electrons as lone pairs on the terminal atoms (except hydrogen) to complete their valence shells with an octet of electrons.
   • There are no remaining electrons on SiH₄, so it is unchanged:
     
4. Place all remaining electrons on the central atom.
   • For SiH₄, ${\text{CHO}}_2{}^{\text{−}},$ and NO⁺, there are no remaining electrons; we already placed all of the electrons determined in Step 1.
   • For OF₂, we had 16 electrons remaining in Step 3, and we placed 12, leaving 4 to be placed on the central atom:
     
5. Rearrange the electrons of the outer atoms to make multiple bonds with the central atom in order to obtain octets wherever possible.
   • SiH₄: Si already has an octet, so nothing needs to be done.
   • ${\text{CHO}}_2{}^{\text{−}}:$ We have distributed the valence electrons as lone pairs on the oxygen atoms, but the carbon atom lacks an octet:
     
   • NO⁺: For this ion, we added eight valence electrons, but neither atom has an octet. We cannot add any more electrons since we have already used the total that we found in Step 1, so we must move electrons to form a multiple bond:
     
     This still does not produce an octet, so we must move another pair, forming a triple bond:
     
   • In OF₂, each atom has an octet as drawn, so nothing changes.

Example 4.6

Writing Lewis Structures

NASA’s Cassini-Huygens mission detected a large cloud of toxic hydrogen cyanide (HCN) on Titan, one of Saturn’s moons. Titan also contains ethane (H₃CCH₃), acetylene (HCCH), and ammonia (NH₃). What are the Lewis structures of these molecules?

Solution

1. Step 1. Calculate the number of valence electrons.
   HCN: (1 $\times$ 1) + (4 $\times$ 1) + (5 $\times$ 1) = 10
   H₃CCH₃: (1 $\times$ 3) + (2 $\times$ 4) + (1 $\times$ 3) = 14
   HCCH: (1 $\times$ 1) + (2 $\times$ 4) + (1 $\times$ 1) = 10
   NH₃: (5 $\times$ 1) + (3 $\times$ 1) = 8
2. Step 2. Draw a skeleton and connect the atoms with single bonds. Remember that H is never a central atom:
   
3. Step 3. Where needed, distribute electrons to the terminal atoms:
   
   HCN: six electrons placed on N
   H₃CCH₃: no electrons remain
   HCCH: no terminal atoms capable of accepting electrons
   NH₃: no terminal atoms capable of accepting electrons
4. Step 4. Where needed, place remaining electrons on the central atom:
   
   HCN: no electrons remain
   H₃CCH₃: no electrons remain
   HCCH: four electrons placed on carbon
   NH₃: two electrons placed on nitrogen
5. Step 5. Where needed, rearrange electrons to form multiple bonds in order to obtain an octet on each atom:
   HCN: form two more C–N bonds
   H₃CCH₃: all atoms have the correct number of electrons
   HCCH: form a triple bond between the two carbon atoms
   NH₃: all atoms have the correct number of electrons
   

Check Your Learning

Both carbon monoxide, CO, and carbon dioxide, CO₂, are products of the combustion of fossil fuels. Both of these gases also cause problems: CO is toxic and CO₂ has been implicated in global climate change. What are the Lewis structures of these two molecules?

Answer:

How Sciences Interconnect

Fullerene Chemistry

Carbon, in various forms and compounds, has been known since prehistoric times, . Soot has been used as a pigment (often called carbon black) for thousands of years. Charcoal, high in carbon content, has likewise been critical to human development. Carbon is the key additive to iron in the steelmaking process, and diamonds have a unique place in both culture and industry. With all this usage came significant study, particularly with the emergence of organic chemistry. And even with all the known forms and functions of the element, scientists began to uncover the potential for even more varied and extensive carbon structures.

As early as the 1960s, chemists began to observe complex carbon structures, but they had little evidence to support their concepts, or their work did not make it into the mainstream. Eiji Osawa predicted a spherical form based on observations of a similar structure, but his work was not widely known outside Japan. In a similar manner, the most comprehensive advance was likely computational chemist Elena Galpern's, who in 1973 predicted a highly stable, 60-carbon molecule; her work was also isolated to her native Russia. Still later, Harold Kroto, working with Canadian radio astronomers, sought to uncover the nature of long carbon chains that had been discovered in interstellar space.

Kroto sought to use a machine developed by Richard Smalley's team at Rice University to learn more about these structures. Together with Robert Curl, who had introduced them, and three graduate students—James Heath, Sean O’Brien, and Yuan Liu—they performed an intensive series of experiments that led to a major discovery.

In 1996, the Nobel Prize in Chemistry was awarded to Richard Smalley (Figure 4.12), Robert Curl, and Harold Kroto for their work in discovering a new form of carbon, the C₆₀ buckminsterfullerene molecule (Figure 4.1). An entire class of compounds, including spheres and tubes of various shapes, were discovered based on C_60. This type of molecule, called a fullerene, shows promise in a variety of applications. Because of their size and shape, fullerenes can encapsulate other molecules, so they have shown potential in various applications from hydrogen storage to targeted drug delivery systems. They also possess unique electronic and optical properties that have been put to good use in solar powered devices and chemical sensors.

Figure 4.12 Richard Smalley (1943–2005), a professor of physics, chemistry, and astronomy at Rice University, was one of the leading advocates for fullerene chemistry. Upon his death in 2005, the US Senate honored him as the “Father of Nanotechnology.” (credit: United States Department of Energy)

Exceptions to the Octet Rule

Many covalent molecules have central atoms that do not have eight electrons in their Lewis structures. These molecules fall into three categories:

• Odd-electron molecules have an odd number of valence electrons, and therefore have an unpaired electron.
• Electron-deficient molecules have a central atom that has fewer electrons than needed for a noble gas configuration.
• Hypervalent molecules have a central atom that has more electrons than needed for a noble gas configuration.

Electron-deficient Molecules

We will also encounter a few molecules that contain central atoms that do not have a filled valence shell. Generally, these are molecules with central atoms from groups 2 and 13, outer atoms that are hydrogen, or other atoms that do not form multiple bonds. For example, molecules of beryllium dihydride, BeH₂, and boron trifluoride, BF₃, contain central atoms with only two and three valence electrons, respectively. With only H as outer atoms, there is just one possibility for the Lewis structure of BeH₂, and it does not satisfy the octet rule for the central Be atom (see as follows). It is possible to draw a structure with a double bond between a boron atom and a fluorine atom in BF₃, satisfying the octet rule, but experimental evidence indicates the bond lengths are closer to that expected for B–F single bonds. This suggests the best Lewis structure has three B–F single bonds and an electron deficient boron. The reactivity of the compound is also consistent with an electron deficient boron. However, the B–F bonds are slightly shorter than what is actually expected for B–F single bonds, indicating that some double bond character is found in the actual molecule.

An atom like the boron atom in BF₃, which does not have eight electrons, is very reactive. It readily combines with a molecule containing an atom with a lone pair of electrons. For example, NH₃ reacts with BF₃ because the lone pair on nitrogen can be shared with the boron atom:

Hypervalent Molecules

Elements in the second period of the periodic table (n = 2) can accommodate only eight electrons in their valence shell orbitals because they have only four valence orbitals (one 2s and three 2p orbitals). Elements in the third and higher periods (n ≥ 3) have more than four valence orbitals and can share more than four pairs of electrons with other atoms because they have empty d orbitals in the same shell. Molecules formed from these elements are sometimes called hypervalent molecules. Figure 4.13 shows the Lewis structures for two hypervalent molecules, PCl₅ and SF_6.

Figure 4.13 In PCl₅, the central atom phosphorus shares five pairs of electrons. In SF₆, sulfur shares six pairs of electrons.

In some hypervalent molecules, such as IF₅ and XeF₄, some of the electrons in the outer shell of the central atom are lone pairs:

When we write the Lewis structures for these molecules, we find that we have electrons left over after filling the valence shells of the outer atoms with eight electrons. These additional electrons must be assigned to the central atom.

Example 4.7

Writing Lewis Structures: Octet Rule Violations

Xenon is a noble gas, but it forms a number of stable compounds. We examined XeF₄ earlier. What are the Lewis structures of XeF₂ and XeF₆?

Solution

We can draw the Lewis structure of any covalent molecule by following the six steps discussed earlier. In this case, we can condense the last few steps, since not all of them apply.

1. Step 1. Calculate the number of valence electrons:
   XeF₂: 8 + (2 $\times$ 7) = 22
   XeF₆: 8 + (6 $\times$ 7) = 50
2. Step 2. Draw a skeleton joining the atoms by single bonds. Xenon will be the central atom because fluorine cannot be a central atom:
   
3. Step 3. Distribute the remaining electrons.
   XeF₂: We place three lone pairs of electrons around each F atom, accounting for 12 electrons and giving each F atom 8 electrons. Thus, six electrons (three lone pairs) remain. These lone pairs must be placed on the Xe atom. This is acceptable because Xe atoms have empty valence shell d orbitals and can accommodate more than eight electrons. The Lewis structure of XeF₂ shows two bonding pairs and three lone pairs of electrons around the Xe atom:
   
   XeF₆: We place three lone pairs of electrons around each F atom, accounting for 36 electrons. Two electrons remain, and this lone pair is placed on the Xe atom:
   

Check Your Learning

The halogens form a class of compounds called the interhalogens, in which halogen atoms covalently bond to each other. Write the Lewis structures for the interhalogens BrCl₃ and ${\text{ICl}}_4{}^{\text{−}}.$

Answer: