- Explain the difference between the scalar product and the vector product of two vectors.
- Determine the scalar product of two vectors.
- Determine the vector product of two vectors.
- Describe how the products of vectors are used in physics.
A vector can be multiplied by another vector but may not be divided by another vector. There are two kinds of products of vectors used broadly in physics and engineering. One kind of multiplication is a scalar multiplication of two vectors. Taking a scalar product of two vectors results in a number (a scalar), as its name indicates. Scalar products are used to define work and energy relations. For example, the work that a force (a vector) performs on an object while causing its displacement (a vector) is defined as a scalar product of the force vector with the displacement vector. A quite different kind of multiplication is a vector multiplication of vectors. Taking a vector product of two vectors returns as a result a vector, as its name suggests. Vector products are used to define other derived vector quantities. For example, in describing rotations, a vector quantity called torque is defined as a vector product of an applied force (a vector) and its distance from pivot to force (a vector). It is important to distinguish between these two kinds of vector multiplications because the scalar product is a scalar quantity and a vector product is a vector quantity.
The Scalar Product of Two Vectors (the Dot Product)
Scalar multiplication of two vectors yields a scalar product.
The scalar product of two vectors and is a number defined by the equation
where is the angle between the vectors (shown in Figure 2.27). The scalar product is also called the dot product because of the dot notation that indicates it.
In the definition of the dot product, the direction of angle does not matter, and can be measured from either of the two vectors to the other because . The dot product is a negative number when and is a positive number when . Moreover, the dot product of two parallel vectors is , and the dot product of two antiparallel vectors is . The scalar product of two orthogonal vectors vanishes: . The scalar product of a vector with itself is the square of its magnitude:
The Scalar Product For the vectors shown in Figure 2.13, find the scalar product .
Solution A straightforward calculation gives us
In the Cartesian coordinate system, scalar products of the unit vector of an axis with other unit vectors of axes always vanish because these unit vectors are orthogonal:
In these equations, we use the fact that the magnitudes of all unit vectors are one: . For unit vectors of the axes, Equation 2.28 gives the following identities:
The scalar product can also be interpreted as either the product of B with the projection of vector onto the direction of vector (Figure 2.27(b)) or the product of A with the projection of vector onto the direction of vector (Figure 2.27(c)):
For example, in the rectangular coordinate system in a plane, the scalar x-component of a vector is its dot product with the unit vector , and the scalar y-component of a vector is its dot product with the unit vector :
Scalar multiplication of vectors is commutative,
and obeys the distributive law:
We can use the commutative and distributive laws to derive various relations for vectors, such as expressing the dot product of two vectors in terms of their scalar components.
When the vectors in Equation 2.27 are given in their vector component forms,
we can compute their scalar product as follows:
Since scalar products of two different unit vectors of axes give zero, and scalar products of unit vectors with themselves give one (see Equation 2.29 and Equation 2.30), there are only three nonzero terms in this expression. Thus, the scalar product simplifies to
We can use Equation 2.33 for the scalar product in terms of scalar components of vectors to find the angle between two vectors. When we divide Equation 2.27 by AB, we obtain the equation for , into which we substitute Equation 2.33:
Angle between vectors and is obtained by taking the inverse cosine of the expression in Equation 2.34.
Angle between Two Forces Three dogs are pulling on a stick in different directions, as shown in Figure 2.28. The first dog pulls with force , the second dog pulls with force , and the third dog pulls with force . What is the angle between forces and ?
Strategy The components of force vector are , , and , whereas those of force vector are , , and . Computing the scalar product of these vectors and their magnitudes, and substituting into Equation 2.34 gives the angle of interest.
Solution The magnitudes of forces and are
Substituting the scalar components into Equation 2.33 yields the scalar product
Finally, substituting everything into Equation 2.34 gives the angle
Significance Notice that when vectors are given in terms of the unit vectors of axes, we can find the angle between them without knowing the specifics about the geographic directions the unit vectors represent. Here, for example, the +x-direction might be to the east and the +y-direction might be to the north. But, the angle between the forces in the problem is the same if the +x-direction is to the west and the +y-direction is to the south.
The Work of a Force When force pulls on an object and when it causes its displacement , we say the force performs work. The amount of work the force does is the scalar product . If the stick in Example 2.16 moves momentarily and gets displaced by vector , how much work is done by the third dog in Example 2.16?
Strategy We compute the scalar product of displacement vector with force vector , which is the pull from the third dog. Let’s use to denote the work done by force on displacement .
Solution Calculating the work is a straightforward application of the dot product:
Significance The SI unit of work is called the joule , where 1 J = 1 . The unit can be written as , so the answer can be expressed as .
The Vector Product of Two Vectors (the Cross Product)
Vector multiplication of two vectors yields a vector product.
The vector product of two vectors and is denoted by and is often referred to as a cross product. The vector product is a vector that has its direction perpendicular to both vectors and . In other words, vector is perpendicular to the plane that contains vectors and , as shown in Figure 2.29. The magnitude of the vector product is defined as
where angle , between the two vectors, is measured from vector (first vector in the product) to vector (second vector in the product), as indicated in Figure 2.29, and is between and .
According to Equation 2.35, the vector product vanishes for pairs of vectors that are either parallel or antiparallel because .
On the line perpendicular to the plane that contains vectors and there are two alternative directions—either up or down, as shown in Figure 2.29—and the direction of the vector product may be either one of them. In the standard right-handed orientation, where the angle between vectors is measured counterclockwise from the first vector, vector points upward, as seen in Figure 2.29(a). If we reverse the order of multiplication, so that now comes first in the product, then vector must point downward, as seen in Figure 2.29(b). This means that vectors and are antiparallel to each other and that vector multiplication is not commutative but anticommutative. The anticommutative property means the vector product reverses the sign when the order of multiplication is reversed:
The corkscrew right-hand rule is a common mnemonic used to determine the direction of the vector product. As shown in Figure 2.30, a corkscrew is placed in a direction perpendicular to the plane that contains vectors and , and its handle is turned in the direction from the first to the second vector in the product. The direction of the cross product is given by the progression of the corkscrew.
The Torque of a ForceThe mechanical advantage that a familiar tool called a wrench provides (Figure 2.31) depends on magnitude F of the applied force, on its direction with respect to the wrench handle, and on how far from the nut this force is applied. The distance R from the nut to the point where force vector is attached is represented by the radial vector . The physical vector quantity that makes the nut turn is called torque (denoted by , and it is the vector product of the distance between the pivot to force with the force: .
To loosen a rusty nut, a 20.00-N force is applied to the wrench handle at angle and at a distance of 0.25 m from the nut, as shown in Figure 2.31(a). Find the magnitude and direction of the torque applied to the nut. What would the magnitude and direction of the torque be if the force were applied at angle , as shown in Figure 2.31(b)? For what value of angle does the torque have the largest magnitude?
Strategy We adopt the frame of reference shown in Figure 2.31, where vectors and lie in the xy-plane and the origin is at the position of the nut. The radial direction along vector (pointing away from the origin) is the reference direction for measuring the angle because is the first vector in the vector product . Vector must lie along the z-axis because this is the axis that is perpendicular to the xy-plane, where both and lie. To compute the magnitude , we use Equation 2.35. To find the direction of , we use the corkscrew right-hand rule (Figure 2.30).
SolutionFor the situation in (a), the corkscrew rule gives the direction of in the positive direction of the z-axis. Physically, it means the torque vector points out of the page, perpendicular to the wrench handle. We identify F = 20.00 N and R = 0.25 m, and compute the magnitude using Equation 2.35:
For the situation in (b), the corkscrew rule gives the direction of in the negative direction of the z-axis. Physically, it means the vector points into the page, perpendicular to the wrench handle. The magnitude of this torque is
The torque has the largest value when , which happens when . Physically, it means the wrench is most effective—giving us the best mechanical advantage—when we apply the force perpendicular to the wrench handle. For the situation in this example, this best-torque value is .
Significance When solving mechanics problems, we often do not need to use the corkscrew rule at all, as we’ll see now in the following equivalent solution. Notice that once we have identified that vector lies along the z-axis, we can write this vector in terms of the unit vector of the z-axis:
In this equation, the number that multiplies is the scalar z-component of the vector . In the computation of this component, care must be taken that the angle is measured counterclockwise from (first vector) to (second vector). Following this principle for the angles, we obtain for the situation in (a), and we obtain for the situation in (b). In the latter case, the angle is negative because the graph in Figure 2.31 indicates the angle is measured clockwise; but, the same result is obtained when this angle is measured counterclockwise because and . In this way, we obtain the solution without reference to the corkscrew rule. For the situation in (a), the solution is ; for the situation in (b), the solution is .
Similar to the dot product (Equation 2.32), the cross product has the following distributive property:
The distributive property is applied frequently when vectors are expressed in their component forms, in terms of unit vectors of Cartesian axes.
When we apply the definition of the cross product, Equation 2.35, to unit vectors , , and that define the positive x-, y-, and z-directions in space, we find that
All other cross products of these three unit vectors must be vectors of unit magnitudes because , , and are orthogonal. For example, for the pair and , the magnitude is . The direction of the vector product must be orthogonal to the xy-plane, which means it must be along the z-axis. The only unit vectors along the z-axis are or . By the corkscrew rule, the direction of vector must be parallel to the positive z-axis. Therefore, the result of the multiplication is identical to . We can repeat similar reasoning for the remaining pairs of unit vectors. The results of these multiplications are
Notice that in Equation 2.39, the three unit vectors , , and appear in the cyclic order shown in a diagram in Figure 2.32(a). The cyclic order means that in the product formula, follows and comes before , or follows and comes before , or follows and comes before . The cross product of two different unit vectors is always a third unit vector. When two unit vectors in the cross product appear in the cyclic order, the result of such a multiplication is the remaining unit vector, as illustrated in Figure 2.32(b). When unit vectors in the cross product appear in a different order, the result is a unit vector that is antiparallel to the remaining unit vector (i.e., the result is with the minus sign, as shown by the examples in Figure 2.32(c) and Figure 2.32(d). In practice, when the task is to find cross products of vectors that are given in vector component form, this rule for the cross-multiplication of unit vectors is very useful.
Suppose we want to find the cross product for vectors and . We can use the distributive property (Equation 2.37), the anticommutative property (Equation 2.36), and the results in Equation 2.38 and Equation 2.39 for unit vectors to perform the following algebra:
When performing algebraic operations involving the cross product, be very careful about keeping the correct order of multiplication because the cross product is anticommutative. The last two steps that we still have to do to complete our task are, first, grouping the terms that contain a common unit vector and, second, factoring. In this way we obtain the following very useful expression for the computation of the cross product:
In this expression, the scalar components of the cross-product vector are
When finding the cross product, in practice, we can use either Equation 2.35 or Equation 2.40, depending on which one of them seems to be less complex computationally. They both lead to the same final result. One way to make sure if the final result is correct is to use them both.
A Particle in a Magnetic Field When moving in a magnetic field, some particles may experience a magnetic force. Without going into details—a detailed study of magnetic phenomena comes in later chapters—let’s acknowledge that the magnetic field is a vector, the magnetic force is a vector, and the velocity of the particle is a vector. The magnetic force vector is proportional to the vector product of the velocity vector with the magnetic field vector, which we express as . In this equation, a constant takes care of the consistency in physical units, so we can omit physical units on vectors and . In this example, let’s assume the constant is positive.
A particle moving in space with velocity vector enters a region with a magnetic field and experiences a magnetic force. Find the magnetic force on this particle at the entry point to the region where the magnetic field vector is (a) and (b) . In each case, find magnitude F of the magnetic force and angle the force vector makes with the given magnetic field vector .
Strategy First, we want to find the vector product , because then we can determine the magnetic force using . Magnitude F can be found either by using components, , or by computing the magnitude directly using Equation 2.35. In the latter approach, we would have to find the angle between vectors and . When we have , the general method for finding the direction angle involves the computation of the scalar product and substitution into Equation 2.34. To compute the vector product we can either use Equation 2.40 or compute the product directly, whichever way is simpler.
Solution The components of the velocity vector are , , and .
(a) The components of the magnetic field vector are , , and . Substituting them into Equation 2.41 gives the scalar components of vector :
Thus, the magnetic force is and its magnitude is
To compute angle , we may need to find the magnitude of the magnetic field vector,
and the scalar product :
Now, substituting into Equation 2.34 gives angle :
Hence, the magnetic force vector is perpendicular to the magnetic field vector. (We could have saved some time if we had computed the scalar product earlier.)
(b) Because vector has only one component, we can perform the algebra quickly and find the vector product directly:
The magnitude of the magnetic force is
Because the scalar product is
the magnetic force vector is perpendicular to the magnetic field vector .
Significance Even without actually computing the scalar product, we can predict that the magnetic force vector must always be perpendicular to the magnetic field vector because of the way this vector is constructed. Namely, the magnetic force vector is the vector product and, by the definition of the vector product (see Figure 2.29), vector must be perpendicular to both vectors and .
Given two vectors and , find (a) , (b) , (c) the angle between and , and (d) the angle between and vector .
In conclusion to this section, we want to stress that “dot product” and “cross product” are entirely different mathematical objects that have different meanings. The dot product is a scalar; the cross product is a vector. Later chapters use the terms dot product and scalar product interchangeably. Similarly, the terms cross product and vector product are used interchangeably.